
Date: Wednesday, 4 May 2011
Posted by: EL
Curator: MS
Attendees: MS, CE & EL
All photos by EL of WednesdayWalkingClub ©2011
MS has brought in this amazing book called “Lost London 1870 - 1945” by Philip Davies, it featured photos of pre-WWII of London. We had an idea of visiting the sites where the original photo was taken and examining what has changed since and what has remained.

Book jacket of “Lost London 1870-1945” by Philip Davies.
Note: All “THEN” images in this post were extracted from this book.
03.1 Crutched Friars
We started off this week’s walk from our street on Crutched Friars heading towards Mark Lane, under the train arch, to our left is Mint Hotel.
THEN:Crutched Friars, 20 June 1912
View looking west to Hart Street and Mark Lane from beneath the arch to Fenchurch Street railway station with railway offices to the right.

THIS IS NOW:Crutched Friars, o4 May 2011.

THEN & NOW: A digital composition by EL.
As you can see, main buildings on the left remains the same. Most buildings on the left have been overtaken by Mint Hotel.

DECODED: Here is the comparison 1912 vs 2011

We continued on our journey to the other end of the street and looking back at the Fenchurch St Station’s arch. On my right now is St. Oalve’s.
THEN: Crutched Friars, 20 June 1912
View along Crutched Friars from New London Street looking east towards the end of Fenchurch Street station. To the right is the side of St Olave’s, Hart Street, the model for “St Ghastly, Grim” in Dickens’ The Uncommercial Traveller with Seething Lane beyond. On the pavement is a cast-iron firm alarm pillar, once a common item of street furniture, now entirely vanished.

THIS IS NOW:Crutched Friars, o4 May 2011

DECODED: Here is the comparison 1912 vs 2011

Next up, we went down Seething Lane and weaved around Pepys Street and arrived at Trinity House on Savage Gardens. North-east of Trinity Square.
03.2 Savage Gardens
THEN: Savage Gardens, Tower, 20 June 1913
View looking north from Trinity Square with the side of Trinity House to the right.

THIS IS NOW: Savage Gardens, o4 May 2011

Despite the building on the left looks “old”, clearly it was built after the “THEN” photo was taken in 1913. The lovely Georgian houses at the end of the street is now the stylish Mint Hotel. The building next to Trinity House seems like the original structure was kept but since have been worked on quite a bit.
DECODED: Here is the comparison 1913 vs 2011

We weaved through the busy Trinity Square, Tower Hill Station and around north side of Tower of London, onto Tower Bridge. We then made a left and headed to Bulter’s Wharf for our last site – Shad Thames.
03.03 Shad Thames
THEN: Shad Thames, c 1910
Much of the river was lined by vertiginous warehouses creating dark canyons separated by slit-like alleys leading to ancient stairs, jetties and wharves. At Shad Thames a myriad of iron bridges spanned the street to allow goods to be moved across the walkways to warehouses inland.

THIS IS NOW: Shad Thames, o4 May 2011

I didn’t create a decoded nor a composition. I believe original image from the book was taken at least from the first or 2nd floor, I will never get the image stack up. Once use as transporting goods to the other building, now these lovely bridges are balconies for some lucky posh residence who live in this Wharf.
Here is our route this week:
View 03. Then & Now I: Crutched Friars, Savage Garden, Shad Thames in a larger map
What do you think of this post? Is a city suppose to move forward with modern architecture or try to preserve the original historical buildings?